Why Do Active Funds Lag Even With Winning Picks?

Picking winning stocks is just part of the battle to beat an index. Active managers make investing moves when opportunities arise or dry up. They also rely on a team of analysts and state-of-the-art tools to help them uncover the next big investment idea. Yet, an in-depth dive into the top 100 largest active US stock funds reveals most active managers earn lower returns than their index. So, what are the pros' missteps? And what can everyday investors like you learn from them? Jeff Ptak analyzed years of stock fund data. The managing director of manager research for Morningstar explains what he found.

The Biggest Active Stock Funds Picked the Right Stocks. They Still Lagged (morningstar.com/funds/biggest-active-stock-fun…)

On this episode:

00:00:00 Welcome

00:00:55 What is a hypothetical 'do-nothing' portfolio?

00:02:54 Hits and misses during 2025's strong market

00:04:16 The do-nothing portfolio's performance during up and down years

00:05:17 Hypothetical $10K growth over a decade

00:06:27 How active managers can do a better job of beating their index

00:07:35 Overcoming the urge to make portfolio tweaks

Watch more from Morningstar:

Target-Date Funds With Annuities Are Gaining Ground. Is That Good for Your Retirement Plan? (morningstar.com/podcasts/investing-insights/ta…)

AI ETFs Are on the Rise. Are They Worth the Risk? (morningstar.com/podcasts/investing-insights/ai…)

Don’t Leave Tax Savings on the Table: How to Conduct a Midyear IRA Checkup (morningstar.com/podcasts/investing-insights/do…)

Follow Morningstar on social:

Facebook: facebook.com/MorningstarInc 

X: x.com/MorningstarInc

Instagram: instagram.com/morningstarinc 

LinkedIn: linkedin.com/company/morningstar

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.