Promotions Gone Wrong? Why False Promises Wreck Trust at Work 6 | 46

Missed promotions, broken promises, and the fallout that follows.

Promotions gone wrong? Yeah, it’s a thing. On this episode, Kim and former Twitter CEO Dick Costolo tackle a listener’s tale of missed opportunities, broken promises, and a management team that just can’t get it together. From the cringe-worthy red flags to the frustrating aftermath, they explore how leadership missteps can wreak havoc on trust and motivation. Tune in for sharp insights, practical advice, and a whole lot of “what NOT to do” when navigating messy workplace dynamics. If you’ve ever felt stuck in a system that doesn’t seem to work, this episode will help you find your way forward. Get all of the show notes at RadicalCandor.com/podcast (radicalcandor.com/podcast/promotions-dick-cost…).

Episode Links:

• Transcript (share.descript.com/view/Ln2gTnkEjwO)

• Managerial Musings With Kim Scott & Dick Costolo 5 | 26 (radicalcandor.com/podcast/s5-ep26-managerial-m…)

• Dick Costolo | LinkedIn (linkedin.com/in/dick-costolo-public)

• Kim Scott & Dick Costolo Unpack the Messy Truth About Management Dilemmas (radicalcandor.com/blog/management-dilemmas)

• What Happens When Promotions Go Sideways? (linkedin.com/pulse/what-happens-when-promotion…)

Connect:

• Website (radicalcandor.com)

• Instagram (instagram.com/radicalcandorofficial)

• TikTok (tiktok.com/@radicalcandorofficial)

• LinkedIn (linkedin.com/company/radical-candor)

• YouTube (youtube.com/@RadicalCandor/podcasts)

Chapters:

(00:00:00) Introduction
Kim Scott introduces Dick Costolo, former Twitter CEO and stand-up comedian.
(00:01:45) The Promotion Predicament
A listener's dilemma about missing out on a promotion.
(00:05:00) Missteps by the First Manager
The mistakes of the listener's first manager, focusing on false promises.
(00:08:20) The Boss’s Boss Blunders
The dismissive and damaging responses from the listener's boss’s boss.
(00:09:36) Advice for Employees
Strategies for employees to clarify expectations with management.
(00:12:29) Addressing Subjectivity in Promotions
The challenge of fairness and transparency in dynamic organizations.
(00:14:54) Navigating Difficult Conversations
The value of candid, constructive dialogue over avoidance in leadership.
(00:18:20) A Call for Transparent Processes
How structured processes can prevent workplace dissatisfaction.
(00:20:30) Conclusion

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices