What’s the Snark on Matty Healy x Taylor Swift?

TTPD is Christy and Rachel’s GOAT albums of TS, and we’re so excited to explain the lore in an incredibly in-depth, nearly two hour episode! Taylor Swift and Matty Healy were publicly together for only a few weeks in 2023—but their story was nearly a decade in the making (real Swiftiesk now). We trace their history from a backstage meeting in 2014 to their whirlwind reunion, then revisit Midnights and The Tortured Poets Department for clues about Joe Alwyn, Matty Healy and her long-awaited, anticipated romance, the backlash, and its implosion.

Thank you to our sponsors!

• Find pieces made for real life with Wayfair (wayfair.com). Join Wayfair Rewards to get five percent back on every purchase.

• Make your bed your favorite place to be this season with Quince (quince.com). Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers. Get free shipping and 365-day returns.

• Head to Cure Hydration (curehydration.com) and use code SNARK for 20% off your order. Subscribe and save; you can pause or cancel anytime.

• Explore your style without commitment — get $28 OFF your first month of Nuuly by using code SNARK at Nuuly.com (nuuly.com)!

• 3 Million Butts Love TUSHY. For a limited time Get 10% off TUSHY with the code SNARK at hellotushy.com

• That scratched up pair has done its job. Upgrade today with Zenni! Go to zenni.com/podcast and use code PODCAST15 for 15% off your first order, plus free shipping on all US orders over $65.

• Wrap yourself in luxury with Lola Blankets! Use our code SNARK for 40% off LolaBlankets.com (lolablankets.com) for a limited time

Get ad-free and bonus episodes weekly on our Patreon (patreon.com/snarkbaitpod) — and don’t forget to sign up for our weekly newsletter (substack.com/@snarkbaitpod)! Shop our merch! (depop.com/snarkbaitpod)

Make sure to follow us on Instagram and watch full episodes on YouTube (youtube.com/@snarkbaitpod)!

@snarkbaitpod (instagram.com/snarkbaitpod/?hl=en)

@christynoel__ (instagram.com/christynoel__)

@soph_ross (instagram.com/soph_ross/?hl=en)

FULL LINKS:

• Patreon - patreon.com/snarkbaitpod

• Full video up on YouTube - youtube.com/@snarkbaitpod

• Snark Bait Instagram - instagram.com/snarkbaitpod

• Christy’s Instagram - instagram.com/christynoel__

• Sophie’s Instagram - instagram.com/soph_ross

• Substack - substack.com/@snarkbaitpod

• Merch - depop.com/snarkbaitpod

Approximate Timestamps:

Part 1: The Addendum

00:00 Intro: Recording an Addendum After Taylor's Surprise News

01:20 Patient Zero & the Encore Dropped Mid-Recording: Initial Reactions

03:20 Patient Zero's "Sterile Asylum" Aesthetic vs. the Encore's Flashy Reveal

07:25 Album Release Theories & the Summer I Turned Pretty Comparison

11:30 Debating the Encore & Favorite Eras Aesthetically

16:25 The Lavender Haze/Mad Men Connection Deep Dive

18:00 Closing Thoughts, the Truman Black/Joe Alwyn Connection & Outro

Part 2: The Main Episode

23:40 Intro: Rachel Returns & Setting the Stage on Taylor & Maddie

27:30 Current Album Speculation: Debut Re-Release & November 10th Theories

32:50 Joe Alwyn's Truman Show Picture & the Gaylor Theories Tangent

37:00 Favorite Taylor Relationship Debate & "The Life of a Showgirl" Critique

41:45 Joe Alwyn as a Muse & Christy's "Maddie as OTP" Hot Take

47:30 The Origin Story: Meeting at a 1975 Concert & Early Courtship

53:45 A Friend's Insider Perspective & Disclaimer on Being a Critical Swiftie

57:00 The Quiet Reputation Era Through the 2023 Breakup & Eras Setlist Swap

1:00:10 April 8th: The Official Joe Breakup, Timed to Maddie's Birthday

1:03:00 The Public Proclamation Timeline & the Sudden June 2023 Breakup

1:05:45 Color Symbolism, the Romantic Gesture Theory & Midnights as a Breakup Album

1:09:15 "You're Losing Me," "Midnight Rain" & "The Great War"

1:14:30 "Question...?" & "Maroon": The Foxborough Surprise Song Tied to Maddie

1:16:55 TTPD as a "Postmortem": "So Long London" & Debating "loml"

1:21:25 "Guilty as Sin?," "Fresh Out the Slammer" & "But Daddy I Love Him"

1:26:00 Defending Her Choices & Questioning Taylor's Real Value System

1:31:00 "I Can Fix Him" & the Title Track's Direct Jack/Lucy References

1:35:00 Marriage Imagery, "Fortnite" & the Album's Downward Spiral

1:42:30 Voice Memo Alternate Lyrics They Wish She'd Kept

1:45:10 "I Can Get You Back" & the Wine-Name Coding

1:53:00 "The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived," "The Prophecy" & "The Manuscript"

2:01:10 Final Thoughts, Lighthearted Closer & Outro

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices