The Holder's Downfall | The Eye of the Holder Case Revisited

Ryan and Fr. Carlos Martins go back into the most popular and most frustrating case of season two. A teenager freed. A holder possessed. One unconfessed mortal sin that turned a scheduled exorcism into what Martins calls a failure worthy of J.R.R. Tolkien.

Follow us on IG at instragram.com/exorcistfiles and instagram.com/TheBethea
Follow us on X.com at x.com/ExorcistFiles

Thanks to our Sponsors:
Right now, save up to 20% on mattresses and up to 25% on everything else when you go to Casper.com.
Head to forkfulmeals.com/EXFILES for 50% off your first order today!
Head to Exodus90.com/exfiles and start your 14 day free trial. Seek the Lord...see what happens!
Get 15% off OneSkin with the code EXFILES at oneskin.co/EXFILES #oneskinpod

Timestamps
0:00 Cold Open: The Cracked Photographs
0:45 Back Into the Most Frustrating Case of Season Two
1:31 “A Failure Worthy of Tolkien”
2:39 Why an Exorcist Won't Hear His Own Team's Confessions
5:25 How Do You Scare a Team Without Terrifying Them
7:05 The Goof Named Gary
9:02 The Mortal Sin in the Room
12:16 Shame, and Why Confession Is Not a Deposition
14:16 Sponsor Break: Casper and Forkful
18:05 The Brilliant Deception: “Just Go Serve God”
18:57 Would Contrition Alone Have Cleared Him
20:49 Forgiven and Still Not Ready
22:52 Emergency vs. Scheduled: “Tuesday at 11 a.m.”
25:04 The Houston Foyer
26:46 Did Father Wyatt Ask? On Trusting a Vetted Team
28:33 Rolled Case Audio: “Hot Stuff”
29:35 Sponsor Break: Exodus 90 and OneSkin
33:05 Why the Room Missed It
35:57 Justin: Abandonment, a Gang, and a Blood Oath
38:42 Peons and Generals: Leviathan Takes the Room
40:44 The YouTube Demonologists
42:29 The Moment: Rolled Case Audio
43:58 Demons Don't Jump
45:50 Rolled Case Audio: “Renounce the Affair”
46:38 Why Gary Is Harder Than Justin
48:10 A Powerlifter in Full Manifestation
49:16 He Walks Out, and St. Joseph's Rod Breaks in Three
51:12 The Million-Dollar Question: What Happened to Gary
52:16 “Gary's Name Is Not Gary”
52:36 Who Belongs in the Room
53:57 The Morals, and the Man Who Died in the Wrong Bed
See Privacy Policy at art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.