Ep. 330: When pastors should or should not defend themselves

Contact us. We’d love to serve you (practicalshepherding.com/contact)
Request a stay at a Shepherd’s House Location (practicalshepherding.com/shepherdshouse)
Give financially to support the work of helping pastors thrive (practicalshepherding.com/donate)
Write a review on Apple Podcasts (podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/trench-talk/id10…) or Spotify (open.spotify.com/show/1t6Jyy3vTLfx3xMHieMDYF?s…)
Find out more about the Advancing the Church Equip Conference taking place September 10-11, 2026 in New Albany, IN. (advancingthechurch.com/conference)
(01:45) Biblical Framework: when should/shouldn’t pastors defend themselves?
(03:40) Biblical tension: Jesus’ silence vs. Paul’s self-defense; key NT texts
(06:55) Proposed “template”: personal slights vs. ministerial slander; online smear story
(09:35) Important caveat: abuse, real guilt, and not helping guilty pastors “defend” themselves
(10:28) Clear cases to defend: disqualifying accusations (false romantic relationship story)
(13:09) Private vs. public accusations; defending against allegations of illegal activity
(15:05) Accusations of heresy and doctrinal error; how and why to respond
(19:18) How to defend without being defensive: tone, frequency, and using elders/outside counsel
(23:26) When not to defend: social media critique (“cesspool of wokeness”) and letting it go
(25:39) Critiques of preaching style/length and why not to publicly “answer from the pulpit”
(28:23) Lifestyle criticisms: vacations, cars, “nice things,” and unnecessary self-justification
(31:10) Vacation time example: fear of criticism and the paralysis of people-pleasing
(33:21) Don’t chase gossip; when silence is wiser than trying to correct every rumor
(34:12) Final counsel: humility, prayer, seeking counsel; closing prayer