The Paulie and Dev Show

What's Up With Jay? | The Traitors New Blood Episode 4 Recap

Dienstag, 29. September 2026 · 35 min

MP3

Shownotes

Paulie and Dev are back to recap Episode 4 of The Traitors, and this one quickly becomes the Jay show. From announcing his body-language expertise and then admitting he took the day off from using it, to throwing out accusations during the challenge and scrambling to save another name, Jay brings a level of chaos that Paulie and Dev can’t get enough of.

They also break down Victor’s impossible position as suspicion continues to follow him, Joe’s increasingly impressive Traitor strategy, and the emotional conversation between Joe and Michael that could have major implications for both of their games.

Plus, they debate Katie’s decision to murder Logan, question whether the pressure of being a Traitor is starting to get to her, rate Alan Cumming’s all-black leather look, and unpack a challenge that leaves Jay in serious hot water.

#TheTraitors #TheTraitorsRecap #PaulieAndDevShow #RealityTV #Traitors

Timestamps:

Episode 4 Recap
Jay’s Body Language Expertise
Why Everyone Keeps Coming Back to Victor
Joe and Michael’s Emotional Roundtable Moment
Joe’s Strategy
The Challenge
Jay Turns the Challenge Into Absolute Chaos

HOSTS:
Devin Walker
Paulie Calafiore

PRODUCERS:
Pete Joseph
Marnie Joseph

Connect with The Paulie & Dev Show:

The Paulie & Dev Show on Instagram (instagram.com/thepaulieanddevshow)
The Paulie & Dev Show on TikTok (tiktok.com/@thepaulieanddevshow)
Redemption Cruise Tickets (form.jotform.com/260895473814064 )

0:00 / 0:00